Theme: The Metaphysical Tradition and Its Movements
Co-Sponsor: Theosophical History
Friday and Saturday, October 26 and 27, 2001
California State University, Fullerton
Fullerton, California
Dell deChant
University of South Florida
ChairJames Santucci
California State University, Fullerton
Co-Chair
J. Gordon Melton
Institute for the Study of American Religion
Co-Chair, Facilitator
Friday, October 26
9:00-10:00 Registration and confirmation check in (Titan Student Center)
10:00 Welcome and Announcements
Thomas Klammer, Dean, California State University, Fullerton
Dell deChant, Conference Chair
10:30 Session I - Theory & Method in the Study of Metaphysical Religions
"Time and Grammar: Two Keys to Two Mysteries in New Thought Philosophy"
Arthur Smith - independent scholar"Issues in Classification: Christian Science and Scientology"
Dawn L. Hutchinson - Florida State University
12:00 noon Lunch ("on your own"), followed by lecture (at Titan Center, California State University, Fullerton)
2:00 PM Session II - Scientology
"The Sacred Process: Auditing in the Church of Scientology, International"
Gail M. Harley - University of South Florida"Mythic Order in Scientology"
Dorthe Christensen - independent scholar
3:30 Break
4:00 Session III - Theosophy
"Path to the Masters: Annie Besant's Esoteric School"
Jerry Hejka-Ekins - California State University, Stanislaus"Modern Occultism and Japanese Religions"
Shinichi Yoshinaga - Maizuru National College of Technology
5:30-7:00 Open time for recreation, visiting, collegiality
7:00 Annual Meal (at Marriott Fullerton), followed by Plenary Lecture
8:00 Plenary Lecture
"Reconsidering Nature Religions"
Catherine Albanese - University of California Santa Barbara
9:30 Welcome and Announcements - Dell deChant, Conference Chair
10:00 Session IV - Theosophy
"An Occult Civil War: Conflict in the Theosophical Society Between East and West After H.P. Blavatsky "
Brett Forray - independent scholar"Understanding The History of Theosophy"
James Santucci - California State University, Fullerton
12:00 noon Lunch ("on your own"), followed by lecture (at Titan Center, California State University, Fullerton)
2:00 PM Session V - Swedenborgianism
"Swedenborg and Science of Metaphysical Religion"3:30 Break
James F. Lawrence-Swedenborgian House of Studies at Pacific School of Religion"The Relationship of Emanuel Swedenborg's Religious Vision to American Metaphysical Religions"
Jane Williams-Hogan - Bryn Athyn College
4:00 Session VI - New Thought
"Early Theosophy As Viewed by Divine Science Founder, Malinda E. Cramer"
Robert Winterhalter - Emma Curtis Hopkins College & Theo. Seminary"Prosperity Consciousness and New Thought's Uniqueness"
J. Gordon Melton - Institute for the Study of American Religion
5:30-7:00 Open time for recreation, visiting, collegiality
7:00 Evening Meal (at Marriott Fullerton), followed by Annual Lecture
8:00 Annual Lecture
"The Changing Face of Madame Blavatsky" Michael Gomes - independent scholar
Emma Curtis Hopkins College and Theological Seminary
P.O. Box 5013
Clearwater, Florida, 33758-5013
Church of Religious Science Fullerton
All daytime sessions will be held at the Titan Student Center on the Campus of the California State University, Fullerton. The evening meals and addresses will be at the Fullerton Marriott Hotel, which is adjacent to the campus of CSU, Fullerton.
For specific questions: (714) 278-3727; email: jsantucci@fullerton.edu
For information about CSUF, click here.
For parking, and directions, click here.
For airport information, click here.
For Marriott Hotel reservations: (800) 228-9290
As has been the case since the first regional scholars' conference, it is the intent of the Society to publish the papers that have been presented in the Journal of the Society for the Study of Metaphysical Religion. If you are not already a subscriber to JSSMR, you may enter a subscription at the conference. In consultation with Theosophical History, some conference papers may be selected for publication in that journal.
Subscriptions are $25 per year (2 issues) and memberships range from $15 to $35 for individuals, depending on membership category. Membership includes a subscription to JSSMR. Group memberships are welcomed at an annual rate of $75. Group members are acknowledged as sponsors of JSSMR. For more information, click here.
Dawn L. Hutchinson has a Bachelor of Music with a concentration in Music Composition from
Christopher Newport University and a Master of Arts with a concentration in Religious Studies
from the University of South Florida. She has served in the position of Assistant Dean at
the Emma Curtis Hopkins College and Theological Seminary in Clearwater, Florida, and has
assisted with the Journal for the Society for the Study of Metaphysical Religions. She
is currently pursuing a Ph.D. in Religious Studies at the Florida State University, and holds
a graduate assistant position there. Her areas of interests are in New Religious Movements in
America and contemporary Gnosticism. She has given papers at the 1999 and 2000 conferences of
the Society for the Study of Metaphysical Religion, and is scheduled to give a paper with Dell
deChant at the American Academy of Religion meeting this year.
Gail M. Harley teaches for the University of South Florida Religious Studies Department. She
has taught Religions of India, Buddhism, Life After Death, Introduction to World Religions,
and other popular courses. She has designed the course, World Goddess Traditions, in response
to the revivification of academic interest in the history of the Goddess. She earned her
Ph.D. in the History of Religion and Humanities from Florida State University. Her recently
published book, Emma Curtis Hopkins: Forgotten Founder Of New Thought is the premier
offering in the new series from Syracuse University Press, New Religions in America, edited by
J. Gordon Melton. She is the author of "Unity and the Harmonial Family" in America's Alternative
Religions, edited by Timothy Miller (SUNY Press, 1995). She researches new religious movements, particularly those that have roots in Asian religious philosophy and has conducted field research in Turkey and Russia. Human Rights issues are a current area of research for her. Gordon Melton.
Jerry Hejka-Ekins received his B.A. degree at California State University Stanislaus, and is
completing his M.A. degree in English literature at the same institution. He is currently
President of Alexandria West and an Associate Editor of Theosophical History.
Shinichi Yoshinaga holds a B.A. in the Study of Religion, a B.S. in Biology, and an M.A. in
Literature; all from the University of Kyoto. His Master's Thesis was "History and the
Sacred-The ambiguity of 'History' in Eliade's Religious Thoughts." He is currently a lecturer
at Maizuru National College of Technology. Among his publications are "William James and the
Psychology of Religion" in Pursuit of the Psychology of Religion, ed. Nishihira and
Shimazono (Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press, 2001); "Theosophy and Japanese Religions in the
Modern Ages" in Reports of the Information and Computer Science Center of Maizuru National
College of Technology 29 (2001); "Breathing Exercises and Aura" in Cities Where Gods
Reside, ed. Syukyo-Syakaigaku-no-kai (Osaka: Sobunsya, 1999); "Saucers and the Millenium-
An Essay on Heaven's Gate"in Reports of the Information and Computer Science Center of MNCT
26 (1998); "Psychology and Theism" in The Study of the Philosophy of Religion 10
(1993); and "Psychical Research of William James" in The Study of the Philosophy of
Religion 7 (1990).
Brett Forray graduated from Iowa State University in 1985 in Communications, specializing in
film studies. He has produced and directed numerous documentary and educational programs.
Mr. Forray has been involved with Theosophy for 26 years and has been a member of three
Theosophical organizations for the past 15 years. Since 1996, he has been independently
researching the separation of the American Section from the worldwide organization that
occurred in 1895.
James Santucci received his M.A. degree in Asian Studies at the University of Hawaii (Manoa
campus) and his Ph.D. degree in the Department of Asian Civilizations at the Australian
National University (Canberra,Australia) in Asian Civilization (with emphasis on the Vedas).
He was a member of both the Religious Studies and Linguistics Departments from 1970 to 1993
and is currently a member of the Department of Comparative Religion. Professor Santucci is the
author of La societteosofica, Hindu Art in South and Southeast Asia, An Outline of
Vedic Literature, The Cave Temples of India: A Photographic Exhibit: September 4 -
November 4, 1990, and co-author of America's Religions. He has written numerous
articles for journals and encyclopedias and is currently editor of Theosophical
History, a quarterly journal.
Jane Williams-Hogan is a Professor of Sociology and Carpenter Chair in Church History at Bryn
thyn College, Bryn Athyn, PA. She received her B.A., M.A., and Ph.D. from the University of
Pennsylvania. Her Ph.D. dissertation (1985) was "A New Church in a Disenchanted World: A Study
of the Formation and Development of the General Conference of the New Church in Great
Britain." She was Chair of the 1988 International Symposium on "Swedenborg and His Influence"
and Local Chair of 1999 CESNUR Conference in Bryn Athyn, PA. Her publications include:
"Swedenborg: A Biography" in Swedenborg and His Influence, ed. Erland J. Brock, et al
(ANC, 1988); "The Place of Emanuel Swedenborg in Modern Western Esotericism," in Western
Esotericism and the Science of Religion, ed. Antoine Faivre & Wouter J, Hanegraaff
(Louven, Peeters Press, 1998); and "Discovering the Two Faces of Religious Charismatic
ction-Traditional and Modern: A Methodology," in Approaching Religion, Part I, ed. Tore
Ahlbck (Ibo, Finland, The Donner Institute, 1999). Her "Institutional and Communal Response to
the Writings of Emanuel Swedenborg," in Scribe of Heaven: Swedenborg's Life, Work, and
Impact will be published by The Swedenborg Foundation in 2002.
James F. Lawrence is Acting Dean of the Swedenborgian House of Studies at Pacific School of
Religion. He holds a B.A., economics, University of Texas; M.Div. equiv., Swedenborg School
of Religion; and D.Min. Graduate Theological Foundation. For the past seventeen years has
served in a dual capacity of minister to congregations and as editor and publisher for the
General Convention of Swedenborgian Churches. Today he is Acting Dean of the Swedenborgian
House of Studies at Pacific School of Religion in Berkeley, California and is in a new
doctoral program for Christian Spirituality at the Graduate Theological Union (Berkeley).
J. Gordon Melton is the Director of the Institute for the Study of American Religion and a
research specialist with the Department of Religious Studies at the University of
California-Santa Barbara. He was one of the founders of the Society for the Study of
Metaphysical Religion and served on its constituting board of directors. He is the author of
more than thirty books in American religious history, including the Encyclopedia of American
Religion (6th edition, 1999). Over the years he has assembled one of the largest collections
of New Thought literature in existence, now an integral part of the American Religions
Collection at the Davidson Library at the University of California-Santa Barbara.
Michael Gomes is regarded as the foremost historian of the the Theosophical movement. He is
especially noted for uncovering and publishing archival material that has shed considerable
light on the Theosophical subjects. Among his numerous books and articles are The Dawning of
the Theosophical Movement (1987), the first book devoted to the origin of the Theosophical
movement since H.S. Olcott's Old Diary Leaves; Theosophy in the Nineteenth Century: An
Annotated Bibliography (1994), a massive bibliography that serves as the basis of all
serious study on the subject, and an abridgement of Isis Unveiled, a work which reveals the
genius of H.P. Blavatsky's first significant work devoted to eclectic Theosophy. His most r
ecent work is the Blavatsky Lecture (2000) "Creating the New Age: Theosophy's Origins in the
British Isles." Mr. Gomes is a Canadian citizen born on the Island of Trinidad.
"Time and Grammar: Two Keys to Two Mysteries in New Thought Philosophy"
"Issues in Classification: Christian Science and Scientology"
"The Sacred Process: Auditing in the Church of Scientology, International"
"Path to the Masters: Annie Besant's Esoteric School"
"Modern Occultism and Japanese Religions"
"An Occult Civil War: Conflict in the Theosophical Society Between East and East and West
After H.P. Blavatsky "
"Understanding The History of Theosophy"
"Swedenborg and 'Science' of Metaphysical Religion"
"The Relationship of Emanuel Swedenborg's Religious Vision to American Metaphysical Religions"
"Early Theosophy As Viewed by Divine Science Founder, Malinda E. Cramer"
Annual Lecture
Emma Curtis Hopkins College and Theological Seminary
Lola Mays Theological Seminary
The Society for the Study of Metaphysical Religion
The Unity Church of Clearwater
Unity-Progressive Council
Please return this form if you plan to attend the conference.
Name____________________________________________________________________________________
Address_________________________________________________________________________________
City __________________________ State_____ Zip __________telephone _____________________
Email____________________________________________ Students: enclose a copy of your
current student I.D.
Make checks payable to: SSMR/U-P.C.
(Check all appropriate boxes and include appropriate remuneration.)
Please register as soon as possible if you plan to attend
I am a student with valid I.D. - no charge, I will attend the conference (except for meals)
I am an SSMR member:
two days-$50 (conference, except for meals)
I am not a member: p one day - $50 (indicate which day: Send this form and your check to:
Created Oct. 3, 2001, by Alan Anderson, alan@neweverymoment.com
URL of this site: http://websyte.com/alan/ssmrrg01.htm
(in order of appearance on the program or alphabetically when a joint appearance)
Arthur Smith - independent scholar
This paper explores the grammatical concept of time as tense, as opposed to the physicist's
concept of time as continuum, to unlock two paradoxes found in New Thought philosophy. The
first is the paradox of the two selves, the lesser self or ego and the Greater Self or
God-Self. This paper agues that the Greater Self is the self that exists in the Eternal Now,
and that the ego is an act of the Greater Self identifying with a singular series of past
experiences. It also identifies mental causation as causation in the act of creation, or
causation in the present. It is where all free will is exercised. Physical causation is
actually a relationship between past events-an antecedent cause and a subsequent effect, but
nonetheless between two or more events in the past, where there is no freedom.
Dawn Hutchinson - Florida State University
Many scholars have classified various metaphysical religions as Gnostic. Of special interest
to this paper is the "Gnostic" classification of a nineteenth century group
(Christian Science) and a twentieth century group (Scientology). This paper addresses how the
term "Gnosticism" might be used methodologically to classify both groups. The paper initially
specifies problems posed by the use of the term ("Gnosticism") by scholars of New Religious
Movements. It then focuses on two specific problems relevant to its deployment: (1) the
indescriminant use of the term without effort to define it; and when an effort is made to
define the term, (2) the flawed and ambiguous nature of the definitions. As a solution to the
above problems of using the term Gnosticism as a classification, the use of a generative
mythology as a defining tool is suggested. A working definition of Gnosticism can be
determined from the generative myth to disclose the Gnostic worldview. How adherents of a
particular religion perceive their place in the world determines the worldview of the
religion. Once the Gnostic worldview is established, it can then be compared with that of
Christian Science and Scientology to determine if either can indeed be classified as Gnostic
using this particular methodology. This paper then demonstrates how the resulting working
definition can be used as a basis for the analysis of the two religions.
Gail M. Harley - University of South Florida
The Church of Scientology offers to their members and the community at large an innovative
process designed by their founder L. Ron Hubbard. The process of auditing erases the Reactive
mind where incidents and traumatic events are held in what Hubbard believed was a chaotic
fashion. The goal of auditing to what Scientologists call the Clear state of mind releases
these traumatic episodes and most importantly the postulations that were made at the time of
the incident. This allows the member to function with what Hubbard called the Rational mind.
This paper will focus on academic, field research and experiential data obtained through
personal commitment to the auditing process. This sacred journey is believed to be the
arterial highway to the Clear state of mind which will enable the practioner to cross the
Bridge to higher consciousness.
Jerry Hejka-Ekins - California State University, Stanislaus
For its general membership, the Theosophical Society is a fraternal organization dedicated to
brotherhood, the study of comparative religions and phenomena. On the other hand, members of
Annie Besant's Esoteric School understood that the Theosophical Society was actually founded
under the behest of an invisible world government of enlightened beings. The Theosophical
Society and its ancillary organizations were instruments designed to bring about a new age of
world spirituality and to assist in preparing for the immanent return of the Christ. The
Esoteric School was also a special training ground for the present and future leaders of these
efforts.
Shinichi Yoshinaga - Maizuru National College of Technology
Between the USA and Japan a relationship has existed during the process of their religious
modernization. The role in Japanese history played by the American Protestant Christianity, or
the influence of Japanese Buddhism on American spirituality after the beat generation are such
examples. But there also have been interrelationships and cultural exchanges in the field of
metaphysical and Theosophical thoughts which have been largely ignored. This paper tries to
depict and analyze the three historical cases concerning the course of the imported Western
metaphysical and occult thoughts.
Brett Forray - independent scholar
This article will examine a little discussed period in the Theosophical Society between 1891
to 1896. The two successors of Helena Petrovna Blavatsky in her Esoteric Section of Theosophy
soon became rivals to determine how to fulfill the ongoing mission of the Society after
Blavatsky's death. Both successors, William Quan Judge and Annie Besant, claimed to continue
receiving letters paranormally from Blavatsky's spiritual teachers, or Mahatmas. Judge,
however, was accused of forging his messages. This paper will examine the impact the
Mahatmas' messages had on the management of the Society, with an emphasis on how each
successor believed the Society should continue promulgating its teachings incorporating
either western or eastern modalities of occultism. The ensuing conflict led to Judge's
American Section breaking away to form a new Theosophical organization, as a necessary
means, he thought, to save the Society's mission.
James Santucci - California State University, Fullerton
"Understanding the history of Theosophy" is admittedly an ambiguous title for those who are
familiar with the use of the term. For one, theosophy refers to different movements and ideas
dating from the early Christian era down to modern times. Furthermore, according to Antoine
Faivre, theosophy refers to two discrete concepts that date from the early modern period: the
theosophical current and the Theosophical Society. Are the two completely different as
Professor Faivre suggests? Or are there resemblances that indicate more of a complementarity
in understanding? Finally, regarding the use of the term "Theosophy" as a label for the
Theosophical Societies or the Theosophical Movement in general, there are some unique problems
that theacademic historian must confront when writing an "objective" account of the
organization. This paper will summarize the issues confronting the historian.
James F. Lawrence-Swedenborgian House of Studies at Pacific School of Religion
Emanuel Swedenborg (1688-1772) holds a distinctive place in the history of Western thought as
one of a very few thinkers recognized for historically significant contributions to both
science and theology. His re-tooling of orthodox Christianity is partially characterized by
principles of science, and the resulting blend of insights drew its greatest interest from
metaphysical thinkers outside of mainline Christian streams, many of whom comprised the advent
of the American metaphysical movements between 1830-1930. They held in common a view that healing,
well-being, and spiritual vitality manifest through orderly channels; that is, there is a
science to salvation. Orthodox claims of spiritual authority based on apostolic succession or
on a faith separated from a logical and lawful spirituality were considered wrong-headed. Many
movements appropriated the term science into their very names of definition and identity
(e.g., Christian Science, Religious Science, Divine Science). Swedenborg was a principal
ource for those and related American metaphysical movements of the 19th and early 20th
century. His blend of science and theosophy laid a the foundation for scientific spiritual
practice, and his ideas of "correspondence," "influx," and "degrees" were widely accessed.
This paper will make clear these connections and focus on the common category of activity
among metaphysical movements: healing - and look at popular Mind-Cure authors of the era,
Horatio Dresser and Warren Felt Evans, who were primarily Swedenborg interpreters, as well
as two influential homeopathists, Kent and Boericke; also Swedenborg advocates.
Jane Williams-Hogan -Bryn Athyn College
The religious thought of Emanuel Swedenborg (1688-1772) has long been associated with a
variety of different religious and philosophical traditions. This presentation will explore
the relationship of Swedenborgianism to American Metaphysical Religions, particularly
ariations of New Thought and Theosophy. Because the Swedenborgian perspective is little known,
it is often misunderstood and its attraction to a diversity of innovative religious thinkers
is not clearly understood. In this presentation, therefore, the fundamentals of
Swedenborgianism will be reviewed, in order to open a discussion of its attraction to
nineteenth-century American religious innovators examining,in particular, its relationship to
the attainment of health, wealth and happiness.
Robert Winterhalter - Emma Curtis Hopkins College & Theo. Seminary
This paper will present the views on Theosophy of a major New Thought founder, Malinda E.
Cramer, in an era when both Theosophy and New Thought were at an early state of their history
and development. Malinda E. Cramer founded the Divine Science movement in San Francisco in
1888. This was thirteen years after Helena P. Blavatsky and Henry S. Olcott founded the
Theosophical Society in New York in 1875. Most of the information in this paper will be based
on material from Harmony magazine, which Mrs. Cramer published monthly between October 1888
and April 1906. This includes, but is not limited to, a review of Madame Blavatsky's book,
The Secret Doctrine, which appeared in two installments in the February and March, 1889
editions of Harmony. Cramer's review discusses Blavatksy's statements on the nature of God,
matter, sources of knowledge, mankind, and mind. A significant article, "Is Divine Science
Theosophy or Christian Science?", appeared in the July 1898 edition of Harmony. Another
literary source for the paper will be Cramer's booklet, "God Incarnation Versus Personal
Re-incarnation, Evolution and Karma."
"The Changing Face of Madame Blavatsky"
Michael Gomes - independent scholar
This lecture will offer a review of the differing perceptions and interpretations of H.P.
Blavatsky and her work over the last 100 years.
P. O. Box 5013
Clearwater, FL 33758-5013
5013 East Broadway Rd.
Mesa, AZ 85206
P.O. Box 37
New Port Richey, FL 34656-0037
2465 Nursery Road
Clearwater, FL 33764
P. O. Box 7753
Clearwater, FL 33758-7753
one day-$35 (indicate which day:
Friday
Saturday) (except for meals)
Friday
Saturday)
(except for meals)
two days - $70 (conference, except for meals)
I will attend the conference and one meal, for which I am adding the additional $25 fee:
Student fee (+$25) (p $25 total) (find remuneration enclosed)
Member fee (+$25) (p $60 [one day];
$75 [entire conference] total) (find
remuneration enclosed)
Non-member (+$25)
($75 [one day]; $95
[entire conference] total) (find remuneration enclosed)
I will attend the conference and both meals, for which I am adding the additional $50
($25, per meal) fee:
Student fee(+$50) (p $50 total) (find remuneration enclosed)
Member fee (+$50) (p $100 [entire conference] total) (find remuneration enclosed)
Non-member (+$50) (p $120 [entire conference] total) (find remuneration enclosed)
If you are attending only one day, please indicate which day:
Friday
Saturday
If you desire vegetarian meals, please check here.
SSMR
PO Box 37
New Port Richey, FL - 34656-0037
Latest update Oct. 15, 2001
Visits since Oct. 3, 2001
FastCounter by bCentral